Let the pampered
city breathe
Elsa Lycias Joel
The India growth story has
a darker side that's hardly
ever mentioned but very
much felt, in Delhi. Only
when we started to choke
did we know that we
desperately need a new growth
paradigm that can address the
challenges of climate change,
resource depletion and pollution. If
Beijing followed Rome or Delhi
found Beijing's road rationing a good
idea to reduce air pollution then it's
time we also borrow other sound
policies for green growth from
various countries across the world.
Way back in 45 BC, Julius Caesar had the foresight for whatever reasons
and it did take centuries for Road
space rationing based on license
numbers to be implemented in cities
such as Athens in 1982, Santiago,
Chile in 1986 and extended to 2001,
México City in 1989, Metro Manila in
1995, São Paulo in 1997, Bogotá,
Colombia in 1998, La Paz, Bolivia in
2003, San José, Costa Rica, in 2005),
I'm yet to believe that
Delhi is one of the cities
that has a planned tree
line. Once trees are looked
upon or treated as
nuisances that take up
road or side walk space,
then people will continue
to choke and die.
countrywide in Honduras in 2008
and Quito, Ecuador in 2010. As told
to the parliament by Mr. Prakash
Javdekar, 80 people die every day in
Delhi due to health impairments
associated with cumulative exposure
to high level of particulate pollution.
It's time for resolutions, right?
Shall we resolve to make the place
we live better and livable by the
small yet wise choices we make by
keeping aside our selfish being.
Yes,
it's about better air, water and
environment if not pure. Wait before
you blame it on the sandstorms, our
pseudo-concern will rectify nothing
and let 'chalta hai Yaar' remain a
movie and not our attitude.
If
delhiites had thought that pollution
and climate change would affect
only the Alps's entire winter sports
industry, then it's time they revised
their basics. Levying a pollution tax does not solve the problem of
curbing pollution. Since a fifth of the
pollution in the city is caused by the
traffic, then road space rationing
might help a bit. It's certainly time
that city dwellers across India
realized that as much as we insist
and invest on anything that's
considered part of a community's
infrastructure, we need to do the
same with trees. Statistically, Delhi
may be one of India's greener
metros, but it isn't one of India's
greenest cities, and it's certainly not
in the top green cities in the world
but the most polluted. The city sure
cannot take pride in the abounding
parks, gardens, and manicured
lawns. I'm yet to believe that Delhi is
one of the cities that has a planned
tree line. Once trees are looked upon
or treated as nuisances that take up
road or side walk space, then people will continue to choke and die. The
point is to engineer trees into
infrastructure as such so that they
don't get shoehorned as an afterthought.
Again, urban forests act as
some kind of sink only for the CO2
emissions and photosynthesis can't
take care of the rest of the pollutants
humans create and release into the
atmosphere. Even though every
single human is blessed with a
conscience, excuses come from the
privileged lot who could afford cars
with odd, even and prime numbers.
Education in the first place should
help us lead a good, clean life. Any
development a result of education is
not worth it if it happens at the cost
I'm yet to believe that
First things first. Before we ring in the New Year with fan fare, dinners and fireworks,
please take some time, precisely 1 hr and 35 minutes to watch "The Lorax". It has
everything that we need to take into our head. Most of all, it has an O 'Hare who
doesn't want trees so that he can sell breathable air. Watch the movie attentively or
you will miss his statement "The more smog in the sky, the more people will buy".
This should definitely ring a bell to Delhiites.
of our health. Let's not be selfish. If
you and I think real hard to roll down
our windows, just imagine the plight
of open- air commuters. We should
resolve to not wait on the policy
makers, but willingly avail the metro
that we attempt to flaunt to the rest
of India, use the bicycle tracks and
not operate our ACs at 18 degrees
because it's 19 degrees outside.
According to the Mercer 2015
Quality of Living Rankings, European
cities dominate the top, Delhi, India
ranked at 154. Mind you, all cities are
becoming economically more
prosperous, the number of rich
persons growing by the day, with
more money to spend in malls,
restaurants and multiplexes. But
then, economic growth doesn't seem
like it's synonymous with human
well-being.
Isn't it still so humiliating and
sickening to not know that the US
president had to bring along 20, 000
gallons of breathable air only
because US secret service agents
who had landed in Delhi sufferedweird symptoms of asthma,
dizziness and cough also because we
live in filth? Luckily our President and
PM could also get some fresh air
then. If or not the agent who slipped
into coma was revived is another
research to be done. How do we
then vacuum CO2 or carcinogenic
nanocarbon particles out of air?
Companies that sold out diesel
vehicles may have to recall them
because they emit up to 40 times the
allowable levels of air pollutants that
are called nitrogen oxides. Sounds
like a poor joke? Grapevine has that
POTUS is still anxious about that 6
hrs of his life span being shortened
by his 3 days visit to Delhi.
In our battle against pollution,
technology was long been viewed as
the ultimate savior. But sorry, so
many times so many technologies
are only clunky reminders how
awkward or distant that dream is.
Without resolving to change our
lifestyles, our attitudes, we modern
humans find technologies so
alluring. If only we have had good
reasoning we will know that the
execution of any technology is
fabulously expensive, complex and
grandiose on a scale that boggles the
logical minds.
For example, those space
capsules and submarines extracting
CO2 to maintain breathable air for
crew members is not an easy job.
The process involves putting one
compound, say a hydroxide in
contact with the air which sets off a
chemical reaction that would grab
CO2 thereby incorporating it's
carbon atoms into a carbonate
compound. It doesn't stop with this.
Now, with large input of heat the
carbonate compound have to be broken apart to reconstitute and
trap the CO2. If you read the above
sentences once again slowly, you
might really understand the simple
process. A physicist at Columbia
University confidently says that the
trapped CO2 can be pumped into
the ground. To increase the pressure
in oil wells? Geologists come to our
rescue and declare there is enough
room in the rocks to lock the CO2
forever. An yearly worldwide
vacuuming bill might reach some $5
trillions. So any good mathematician
may calculate the cost for Delhi. Is
S.Kalmadi the right choice! Anyways,
I contend that such blind faith in
technologies is a dangerous distraction from the most urgent
sacrifices we ought to make to
control pollutions of many a kind.
Be it the Kyoto protocol or
COP21Summit or CMP 10, no matter
how we go about it, there will be a lot
of politics. So let's do our own bit, as
citizens, as humans willing to learn
and unlearn for the greater good.
Each one of know what to be done.
Small possible actions that resolve
bigger, dangerous issues of concern
have been said to and taught to us in
as many languages as possible by
activists and experts. Since our
contribution towards emissions is
mostly through the vehicles we
overuse we can think about cleaning
the mess we create though we are all
aware of the famous quote "No
problem can be solved from the
same level of consciousness that
created it". Let's try a bit of
gardening the coming year, plant
trees for they offer a wide range of
functional benefits like sequestering
CO2 and convert it into oxygen,
remove sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxide, counter the urban
heat island effect, reduce wind
speeds and absorb a lot of noise.
Urban planners will recognize the
ecological value of trees once people
start to act. Remember, a banyan or
a gulmohar belongs to a park and
not on a relatively narrow road.
First things first. Before we ring in
the New Year with fan fare, dinners
and fireworks, please take some
time, precisely 1 hr and 35 minutes
to watch "The Lorax". It has
everything that we need to take into
our head. Most of all, it has an O
'Hare who doesn't want trees so that
he can sell breathable air. Watch the movie attentively or you will miss his
statement "The more smog in the
sky, the more people will buy". This
should definitely ring a bell to
Delhiites.
Other than vehicular emissions
that contribute to air pollution in a
huge way, unpaved road dust or
fugitive dust, construction debris,
awful stench emanating from
garbage sometimes accompanied by
the smoke from its burning are
testimonies of air pollution.
Replacing deficient sidewalks, curb
and gutter are as necessary as
addressing the bewildering issue of mud strips between the road and the
sidewalk. Why this impassable space
is for the concerned departments to
ponder over. The number of
agencies, contractors, other public
utility committees or civic agencies
and departments involved should
have proper project co-ordination so
that whatever is in our limits can be
dealt with efficiently as far curbing
air pollution is concerned because
any air pollution prevention or
reduction program must be coordinated
with other programs that
indirectly result in escalating
pollutions. We will still remain in an
embryonic and inefficient state if government agencies engage in
attempts peripheral to air pollution
control program operations. An
integrated approach can indicate
actions that achieve maximum
benefits at low costs and on time in
the best interests of our country.
When aiming for too many
objectives without proper coordination,
more often than not
diverse values offset one another
rather than create synergy. It's for us
to discern how much offsetting
impact the society can afford due to
conflicting values between economy,
lethargy and pollution. Emphasizing the active role of government and
citizens in creating a model for a low
carbon future, for pollution free
cities will make sense only after the
mechanical sweeping machines , an
initiative of the New Delhi Municipal
Corporation (NDMC) are put to use
in the right places. Does this need
political will? With the trend
changing towards more
mechanization, 4 people will be able
to clean 40 kilometers without
I'm yet to believe that
"Every country has the
government it deserves".
Very true. But then again,
"Everyone has the right to
a standard of living
adequate for the health
and well-being of himself
and of his family,
including food, clothing,
housing and medical care
and necessary social
services."
shifting blame or responsibility.
Moreover, Streets and roads aren't
the only places that need brooms.
Then again, the various
recordings of the diameter of total or
respirable suspended particulate
matter levels or just the particulate
matter, by various techniques,
agencies or devices may look like
back of the envelop calculation to
many unless and until details like the
time and place be mentioned for
people to take relevant measures.
Did our PM exhort the world to
'Make In India'? But what has he
made of India! Well, let's not get too
finicky about that $1 bn loan backing
from SBI for the Carmichael mine in
Queensland. After all Adani is Indian
and it's about "Making of an Indian"
which doesn't make a big difference
to "Make in India". It does indicate
how big India's political decision
makers care for the slogans they
tout. Probably its esoteric philosophy only a certain breed can
take in. Though we have drifted
geographically we are all one and the
same should be NaMo's conviction.
Furthermore, there isn't any proof
that the continents won't drift again
to come together as one
supercontinent. Remember
Pangaea!! Whatever we shouldn't be
drifting from what we ought to
discuss here.
The Swacch Bharat campaign
stumped many as all the "King's"
men and their brooms cannot clean
it all up. Remedial propaganda has
been done and more planned. Clean
change happens with enough facility
and infrastructure not with a
bewildering array of government
bodies that don't always integrate
ideas and coordinate activities.
Governments take umbrage at any
suggestion that they need to work on
their credibility with citizens; they
assume they already possess it like
none else. Excuse me, doing their job
is part of their job! We must resist
the urge to categorize pollution as a problem that has to be solved only
by governments alone.
If we could afford, let's buy a
bicycle the coming year, one for each
family. In countries like Belgium,
Norway, Switzerland, Japan, Finland,
Sweden, germany and Denmark
people even the elite and public
servants use bicycles a lot for
commuting. Netherlands is even
called the country of cyclists.
For
those who may not know,
Netherlands is an economic
powerhouse ranked 16th in the
world in terms of GDP. By all
standards the country is rich YET the
prime minister is NEVER driven in
convoys. The most honorable man
Mark Rutte rides a bicycle to work.
Six bicycles can typically fit into
the road space used by 1 car. Parking
advantages are greater. Cycling
reduces chances of cardiovascular
diseases, osteoporosis and arthritis
in addition to strengthening the
immune system. Long distance
travel is quite impractical on a
bicycle but it can be a supplemen for cars on a personal level. To
promote an ecological culture, all
parts of Delhi may be connected by
bicycle paths. Governments should
understand that promotion of
bicycle use is required as a new
paradigm of green transportation to
resolve problems of pollution,
energy and traffic congestion.
"Every country has the
government it deserves". Very true.
But then again, "Everyone has the
right to a standard of living adequate
for the health and well-being of
himself and of his family, including
food, clothing, housing and medical
care and necessary social services."
This is just another universal
declaration and it is up to us to make
it happen in the real sense either by
doing the right thing or by cooperating
with the policy makers if
the policies sound healthy.
At least on the brink of a collapse,
will we gather our energies and
senses to change for better? Support
or protest, horses and cycles help a
lot with separate lanes.