A masterly work !
Dr Graham Ranger
Veteran journalist,
Kishin Wadhwaney,
is to be
congratulated on
publishing his 30th
book, and a very fine
one to boot. Regular readers will
warm up to the skilful blend of
analysis and match-by-match,
series-by-series synopses, all
related to the character and
achievements, highlights and the
(relatively) lower lights signalling
the pathway followed by
irrepressible M.S. Dhoni.
Characteristic of Wadhwaney's
style is his anti-authoritarian
stance, ever seeking to expose
injustice, corruption and the
downright inadequacies of many
of cricket's bureaucrats. Here
though is a carefully crafted
analytical commentary on the
relationship between Dhoni the
man and Dhoni the cricketer and
leader of cricketers.
Destiny is a concept embedded
in Independent India's psyche,
cultures and beliefs, the
inevitable happening of an event
in the future. Immortalised by
Nehru in one of the greatest ever
political speeches, at one of the
most significant moments in the history of modern India, the eve
of independence from the British
colonisers, writers return to it
readily as the idea resonates with
readers.
Wadhwaney provides a
searching analysis of M.S. Dhoni's
fulfilment of his destiny, both as a
leader and as a wicket-keeper
batsman. The author draws on his
extensive experience as a sports
journalist as well as an author to
position the contribution and
legacy of MSD in the canon of
wicket-keeper batsmen and in the
context of the Indian (Test)
selectors' loyalty or the lack of it
to their stumpers.
Wadhwaney provides a
searching analysis of M.S.
Dhoni's fulfilment of his
destiny, both as a leader
and as a wicket-keeper
batsman.
The author identifies limited
overs cricket as the catalyst for
the changing role of the keeperb
a t sma n / b a t sma n - k e e p e r .
However, I think the change came
about through the force of
personality rather than a change
in the game's structure and
diversity. I consider the change to
be more singularly attributable to
the dash of the Australian wicketkeeper
Adam Gilchrist, an
inspiration to many of those who
followed him and a definite gamechanger
in all meanings of the
phrase.
K.R.Wadhwaney
The author produces an
insightful guide to the character
of MS Dhoni, the man as well as
the cricketer. While it is obvious
that the two are inevitably
intertwined, Wadhwaney writes
with warmth, respect and
affection for Dhoni, highlighting
the character, integrity and qualities of M.S. Dhoni as a
human being, emanating from his
supportive and steadfast family,
his relatively unglamorous
background from Ranchi and his
faith.
This is, of course, deserved:
MSD's legacy comes from his
leadership of India to serious
highs in world cricket as well as
the style of the man, perhaps
primarily as a leader and
batsman, rather than wicketkeeper.
However, Dhoni's
keeping abilities are not
neglected. Rather, it is because
the highs and the sense of predestined
triumphs are attributed
more explicitly to his batting and
his captaincy, rather than his
keeping.
Serious questions that occupy
the mind of many a cricket lover
are discussed: should a captain
be picked from the best 11, in
classic Australian style, or should
the captain be picked first and
help shape the 11? Player first or
captain first? Should the best
player be captain, aka Sachin or
Virat Kohli, or should the captain
be worthy of his place on account
of his abilty to inspire others and
his ability as a master tactician?
The English philosophercaptain
Mike Brearley comes to
mind with his ability to bring out
the best in Ian Botham, who was
previously named as captain
himself on account of his allround
playing ability, with
disastrous consequences.
MS Dhoni has put Ranchi on
the world map. Few outside of
India would have heard of the
town previously, and many now
will only have done so because of
MSD. His achievements are even
greater because of his humility, his 'team-first' mentality and his
bravery.
Wadhwaney is up-to-date,
drawing on all forms of the game,
including T20 (IPL and
international) to give a rounded
assessment of Dhoni's legacy. Not a child protegy, at first a
footballer rather than a cricketer,
not from a metro, Dhoni changed
the cricketing landscape and
helped send India to the summit
of the rankings.
Sachin identified the
leader in Dhoni and
advocated for him
wisely and in a timely
manner. In time, Dhoni
himself saw exactly
when the time was right
to stand down and pass
on the leadership baton
to Virat Kohli ; he once
again showed the ability
and the emotional
intelligence few possess.
The book culminates for me in
a crescendo, describing the World
Cup Final against Sri Lanka at the
Wankhede Stadium Mumbai in
2011. The descriptions are
evocative, painting the picture to
enable the cricket-lover to reimagine
her/himself there at the
stadium. The Final epitomised
Dhoni's bravery and his ability to
follow his judgement through to a
successful conclusion. In this
case, he promoted himself above
the in-form Yuvraj Singh in the
batting order, and timed the run
pursuit to perfection, seeing India
home to the World Cup by
clearing the ropes.
Not only that, Dhoni's
immaculate sense of timing and pacing of an innings for his team
meant that the Cup was won
dramatically. Every cricketer
dreams of hitting the winning six
to lead their country home: Dhoni
has lived that dream and
triumphed through it.
Sachin identified the leader in
Dhoni and advocated for him
wisely and in a timely manner.
In
time, Dhoni himself saw exactly
when the time was right to stand
down and pass on the leadership
baton to Virat Kohli ; he once
again showed the ability and the
emotional intelligence few
possess. What is next for MSD?
A career in politics? A
statesman? His leadership
qualities and his ability to bring
the best out of others will be
valuably harnessed for the good
of the common man. Time will tell
but for now, I urge you to read
this book to gain insights into one
of the most prominent cricketing
leaders of his generation.
Wadhwaney has produced a
masterly work, incisive views
supported by a detailed analysis
of international and other
matches that showed MSD's
impact and legacy on the world
game.
Child of destiny? It depends.
Foreign fans will see it as such:
railway ticket collector to national
captain, fulfilling his destiny to
lead India to greatness and be
immortalised not just for doing so
but also for leading and playing
cricket in a style others will
attempt to emulate.
Dr. Graham Ranger is a
cricket fan and a lover of
Indian cricket. He currently
lives and works in Chantilly,
France.