|
FRANKLY SPEAKING
Triple challenge in KashmirNew thinking, new strategies called forPeople lit up candles at India Gate to pay tribute to late Kashmiri Army Officer Lt Ummer Fayaz killed by militants.
Hari Jaisingh
Barbaric acts of the Pakistan
army and their jihadi operators
across the LoC in Jammu and
Kashmir. Mahbooba Mufti For years and years hawala and narcotics networks have been playing a major role in Pakistan's proxy war in Kashmir. The Kashmiri mafia of Lahore has fostered and sustained militancy with its massive funding of separatist Hurriat and mujahideen leaders. The smugglers and narcotic trafficers have generally sought safety through marriage, gifts, business deals or by providing services to these clans. I have talked about these links and other related facts in my book Kashmir : A Tale of Shame published by UBS in 2002. The tragedy of India is that our intelligence agencies and government authorities have overlooked the facts and played their own petty games. Let us see how the Narendra Modi establishment and the National Investigation Agency (NIA) prove to be different this time. I keep my fingers crossed. The stone-pelting students and trouble-makers targeting the security forces and the police, meanwhile, show not only breakdown of law and order but also the marginalisation of the Mahbooba Mufti government's authority and local and mainstream parties' leaders. Young Kashmiris want opportunities for jobs. Adequate employment generation holds the key to wean them away from the wrong track of terror and stone pelting for money. The very fact that 1.18 lakh J&K youths have applied for 5,362 police jobs show how employment generation could make a difference to our fight against terrorism. The ground realities in the Valley are grim and explosive. The political vacuum on the ground has left the field open for Pakistani agents, separatists and azadi slogan-mongers to take the local youth on to a confrontanist path of violence, thereby ruining the State's fragile economy of tourism, allied services and employment generation. Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his team need to work out short, medium and long-term strategies for the management of Kashmir affairs, possible plans of action for dealing with Pakistan as a terror-cumrogue nuclear State and China's dubious role. Against this complex backdrop, history has turned full circle in the Valley as we find the silken threads of Sufism getting snapped, courtesy Saudi Arabia-groomed and Pakistansponsored Wahhabi separatists and azadi elements. They seem to have got a fresh lease of life under the three years of the PDP-BJP regime in Srinagar. The BJP leadership remains as directionless and confused as ever. The saffron party hardly enjoys any presence in the Valley. Ironically, the call by BJP president Amit Shah to its Ministers in the State to reach out to the people in the Valley is nothing but laughable. It shows to what extent the saffron party leadership is out of tune with the ground realities. This is typical of the Bharatiya Janata Party's lopsided approach to Jammu and Kashmir. It was a grave mistake on the part of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's policy-makers and the party's "activists" headed by Ram Madhav and Jitendra Singh to have gone in for an alliance with the PDP in the first place without giving serious thoughts to Kashmiri leaders' track record, their shifting loyalties and ever changing realities on the ground. At best, the party could have given outside support to the Mehbooba Mufti government.
Narendra Modi
There is no point in crying over
spilled milk. What matters today is to
come to the grip of multi-dimensional
complexities in Kashmir both at
operational, policy and decisionmaking
levels.
Syed Ali Shah Geelani
Kashmir is the Number One
National Problem. The Prime
Minister needs to be actively
involved for consultations with all
leaders at the national and state
levels and work towards a
consensus on tackling Kashmir's
internal problems, Pak-sponsored
terrorism and its army's barbaric
conduct across the LoC. It is not an
easy task. This requires serious and
sincere efforts. The security forces
leaders and experts too have to be
kept in the loop. Protesters throw stones on the police in Srinagar
1.18 lakh J&K youths have applied for 5,362 police jobs
possible plans of action for dealing
with Pakistan as a terror-cum-rogue
nuclear State and China's dubious role.
A masked protester gets ready
to pelt stones at the security
forces in Srinagar
Four, it is also necessary to
pinpoint new sources and means
of funding to various segments
of trouble-makers in the Valley. The
latest intelligence papers reveal how
anti-India activities by Hurriat and
others are funded through a known ISI
conduit named Mahboob Ahmed
Sagar(TOI report). A wide network of drug trafficking does exist in the State. It must be identified and destroyed. I expect India's intelligence agencies to give a better account of their performance than has been the case so far. Five, it is absolutely essential for the
security forces to evolve new tactics
and strategies to deal with stonepelting
civilians. We must not forget
that they are our own people. They
have to be handled with care. A civilian death resulting from the cross-fire of an anti-terrorist operation becomes an explosive issue. India's military commanders must think of alternative methods to avoid civilian casualties, howsoever provocative might be the situation. I am sure our military leadership is capable of working out new methodology to deal with stone-pelting youngsters with utmost care and caution. The sole objective should be to avoid direct confrontation with the civilian crowd since a resultant death creates its own chain reactionto the embarrassment of Srinagar and New Delhi authorities. Finally, what is needed urgently
is a healing touch for aggrieved
sections of the population. We need
to appreciate that ordinary
Kashmiri's want peace, harmony
and congenial atmosphere to earn
their livelihood with honour and
dignity.
Farooq Abdullah
Of course, most Kashmiri
politicians as a class, like
chameleons, keep changing colours.
They have different languages for
different occasions. When in power,
they swear by India and seek favours
from the Centre to keep their show
going. When out of power, they strike
anti-India postures.
Power and terrorism today has
become a big business in the Valley.
The latest glaring example in this
regard has come from no other
than former Chief Minister Farooq
Abdullah. Looking back, it is clear that our
entire Kashmir policy has been full of
loopholes. It has mostly been one
personality-oriented rather than
people-oriented, with the result we
invariably get trapped in shadows of
our own making. Take the Sheikh's ethnic policy
pursued by him. It helped to
create the most favourable conditions
for Islamic fundamentalism to grow in
the Valley. Arab money helped the Jammat to organise madrasas in large numbers, which spawned a semieducated new generation of communalised young men. It is these young persons who are providing grist to the militants' mill. They have been responsible for the flight of the Kashmir Pandits from the Valley. The international community did not even shed crocodile tears for the terrible plight of the Pandits? Where is its much-talked about humanism and liberalism? True, Jawaharlal Nehru did build up Sheikh Abdullah to grow larger than life. It is a kind of poetic justice that Nehru denounced the Sheikh before his death. According to B.N. Mullik (My years with Nehru), "Pandit Nehru said all the trouble in Kashmir was due to the Sheikh's communal outlook and it was he who was not allowing the State to settle down to peace and stability".
Jawaharlal Nehru
Sheikh Adbullah died in 1982. But
before his death, he made his
son, Dr. Farooq Abdullah, the
president of the National Conference
and asked the Kashmiris to place their
faith in him, for, he said, his son would
accomplish what he had not been able
to? And what was the Sheikh's
unaccomplished dream?
Independence? He had actually been
nursing this idea for long and for this
purpose he played communal and
Islamic fundamentalist cards. The Sheikh was out and out pro- Sunni. He had a hand in shaping the ethnic identity of the Kashmiris, now referred to as Kashmiriat. This identity has little to do with their ancient culture. His objective was to isolate the Kashmiri Muslims from other Muslims. It also must be stated that the Sheikh was not favourably disposed towards the Kashmiri Pandits. He very much resented secularisation of the Kashmir Muslim society.
Sheikh Abdullah
The Sheikh's communal mind can
be inferred from the fact that he was
ready to rehabilitate Muslims from Central Asia in the Valley, but not the
Hindu refugees from Punjab. Will dividing J&K into three states of Kashmir Valley, Jammu and Ladakh help? This question may be examined by the Centre. The problems of terrorism and militancy have to be dealt with firmly. The sponsors of militancy must know that they are living in an era in which few have faith in "new saviours"-- religious, political, economic or social. Their cause carries no conviction. So, we must bring the militants to their knees through the process of attrition, however slow its progress. The real problem here is Pakistan, its wayward Generals and ISI. They are calling the shots and setting their own agenda to destablise India and grab Kashmir. China has been helping it in its evil designs. Has Prime Minister Modi any effective answer to the growing Pakistan-China axis ? Ironically, on China's home front, Muslim and Islamic ideology are dirty words. Still, Islamabad is working in concert with China. Where is Pakistan's so-called Islamic face? All these bitter facts pose a big challenge to the Modi establishment, which cannot be faced by a straight-line approach. Complexities in the Valley and across its border have put Prime Minister Modi before the people's court of judgement! Gen. Zia-ul-Haq's proxy war has
gone on for decades. The time
has now came for taking risks. We
must be ready to punish Pakistan,
short of war, and bring about radical
changes in the State of Jammu and
Kashmir to stop the insurgency and
sponsorsed terror acts. There is a variety of ethnic groups in the Valley. A thorough understanding of the ethnic differentiation is very important to work out any possible solution to the Kashmir crisis. Apart from the division between Sunni and Shia among the Kashmiri Muslims, there are caste-like groups, though less rigid than among the Hindus. I believe that if peaceful solutions
have to be evolved to silence the guns
of the militants, then there has to be a
precise and determined approach to
men, matters and issues in the
context. |