Nankana Sahib : Pakistan’s
“true face” exposed
Nankana Sahib Gurudwara
Nankana Sahib, the
birthplace of Guru
Nanak Devji, the
founder of the
Sikh religion is a
living symbol of the Sikh faith. It
holds tremendous appeal for the
Sikh and Hindu communities. The
devotees from India and abroad
flock to Nankana Sahib on the
historic occasion of his birthday.
Strained relations between India
and Pakistan, often do create
problems as we witnessed on
Friday, January 3. A mob, led by a
radical Islamist elements who had
forcibly married a Sikh teen,
reportedly threw stones at the
Gurudwara and threatened to
convert it into a mosque to be called Ghulam-e-Mustafa.
The Pakistan government has, however, dismissed Friday’s incident
“as an altercation” between two Muslim groups and said that “attempts
to paint this incident as a communal issue are patently motivated”. This
is an absurd statement on the part of Islamabad authorities, to say the
least.
Harsimrat Kaur Badal
Hardeep Singh Puri
I agree with Union Minister and Shiromani Akali Dal leader
Harsimrat Kaur Badal that the incident “exposed” the “true face” of
Pakistan, where “persecution of minorities is a reality”.
I am, however, shocked by the statement by another Union Minister
Hardeep Singh Puri who had linked the event with ongoing protests
across the country against the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA)
agitation. It is, again, absolutely silly on the part of Minister Puri to link
the two issues. This speaks of a confused state of mind of some of the
Ministers in the Modi establishment.
Religion is sacred. The Sikhs are passionately devoted to their
religious tenets. Islamabad invariably uses religion as an instrument of
politics with a view to dividing people in the subcontinent. It has used
Islam to divide the Indian polity and tried to grab Kashmir by proxy war.
It has also aided and abetted separatist elements in Punjab and other
parts of the country. The ISI has, in fact, spread its subversive network
in every vital area of this country. New Delhi does not seem to have examined the issue thoroughly,
but has provided the right answer
to Pakistan’s mischievous game-plan.
Jinnah believed that
Partition was the right
move. Still, he had
some doubts about it.
“Any idea of a united
India could never have
worked and in my
judgment, it would
have led to a terrible
disaster”, he said. At
the same time, he
added, “Maybe that
view is correct, maybe
it is not. That remains
to be seen”.
Stone pelting at Nankana Sahib Gurdwara in Pakistan
Navjot Singh SidhuHaving failed in its earlier
moves in Punjab, Pakistan has
often made desperate attempts to
spread troubles there with the
help of jehadi elements. Such
attempts are bound to fail. The
people of Punjab have suffered
enough in the past. Leave aside dissent Congress leader Navjot
Singh Sidhu. The people have
learnt their lesson. Navjot Singh
Sidhu is still floating in the air
amidst Pakistan clouds along with
his “friend” Imran Khan.
How shabbily Hindu, Sikh,
Christian and even selective
Muslim groups are treated in
Pakistan is no secret. What is
particularly regrettable is that the
rulers in Islamabad selectively
play politics with the minorities.
Today, Pakistan itself is
sitting on a volcano, which has
forced several ethnic groups to
question the very concept of
Partition. Even Jinnah had
apprehensions in this regard.
Mohammed Ali Jinnah
It may be worthwhile to recall
what Jinnah had said while
addressing the Constituent Assembly in
1947. He
told the
legislators:
“You are
free. You are
free to go to
your temple.
You are free
to go to your
mosque or to
any other
place of worship in this state of
Pakistan”.
“You may belong to any
religion or caste or creed…..this
has nothing to do with the
business of the state of Pakistan.
We are starting with this
fundamental principle that we are
all citizens of our state”, Jinnah
declared.
Jinnah believed that Partition
was the right move. Still, he had
some doubts about it. “Any idea of
a united India could never have
worked and in my judgment, it
would have led to a terrible
disaster”, he said. At the same
time, he added, “Maybe that view
is correct, maybe it is not. That
remains to be seen”.
Interestingly, his “disaster”
remark on his deathbed acquired
some credence in the light of the
doubts expressed by him during
his earlier days. But by then, he
was no more the master of
situation. Things were totally out
of his control. The very inability
of Islamabad to integrate
Mohajirs, the people who were at
the very helm of the Pakistan
movement and who had worked
for their integration into the
Pakistan mainstream speaks a lot
for its shaky ground. It must be a
matter of concern to intelligent
Pakistanis.
The Hindu, Sikh and
all other Indian
communities must
stand together and
fight unitedly against
the communalization
of politics. Guru
Nanak Devji taught us
precisely this at
various fora and in his
holy books.
The Pakistani elite believe the hegemony of the Punjabis and the
Pathans holds the key to political
unity and control over their
country and Islam. This
fundamental vision, they think,
gives it legitimacy. Democracy has
no place in such a society.
Jinnah had never envisaged an
orthodox Islamic state. He wanted
Pakistan to be a liberal state. This
approach continued until, much
later, General Zia-ul-Haq
overturned the Jinnah tradition
and brought in orthodox Islam.
With it, sectarian violence
became the order of the day in
Pakistan.
Amidst these varied
challenges, what is regrettable is
that we lack proper
understanding of Pakistan’s
changing profile. Even the
academic world has neglected
the study of our next-door
neighbour. These serious gaps
have to be bridged, if New Delhi
is serious about proper
evaluation of the crafty mindset of the rulers in Islamabad. It
needs to be realized by the
Indian leadership that political
management of ours must be
made of sterner stuff than has
been the case so far.
As for the people of India, it is
necessary that the Hindu, Sikh
and all other Indian communities
stand together and fight unitedly
against the communalization of
politics. Guru Nanak Devji taught
us precisely this at various fora
and in his holy Guru Granth
Sahib.
In fact, it needs to be realized
that the basic essence of the
Indian tradition cannot be
inculcated without ensuring
religious tolerance. It must not
be politicized.
The main challenge before the
Indian leadership is how to widen
and consolidate the polity’s
secular base as well as basic
national causes to fight against
Pak-sponsored terrorism in J & K
and other parts of the country.