Story of a Dalit family
M. R. Dua
HIDDEN, covert
or arcane, the
u n d e r l i n e d
motive of
p u b l i s h i n g ,
p r o m o t i n g
and approbating this book
appears to be commending
and applauding the religiousconversion
missions
sponsored and supported by
multiple Christian institutions
funded by rich western
nations, particularly America,
Canada, Australia, India and
many other developing
countries.
As we all know that ever
since Christianity arrived in
India 52 AD when St. Thomas
landed in Kerala, the
movement to convert poor and
the downtrodden people to
Christianity is prevalent
unabated until today. The
Christian religious leadersponsors
have been inducing,
luring and incentivizing the
deprived poor and the
disadvantaged people
monetarily, and generously
offering freebees to
convert.This book narrates the
story of a Dalit family that
prospered and flourished after
all its members embraced
Christianity.
Author Sujatha Gilda, a 26-
year-oldDalit woman, whose
ancestors from a tiny Andhra
village had converted to
Christianity in the 1800s,
acquired engineering and
physics degrees from India's most prestigious and elitist
institutions like IIT, availing
herself of reservation
concessions. Her parents also
were employed as college
teachers. She too initially
secured a fairly respectable job
of a researcher in applied
physics in ISRO. However, she
was lured by Canadian
missionaries to migrate, and
she moved to the United States
where she landed in teenyweeny
jobs in banks, etc., and
currently works as conductor
in New York city sub-way
system.
Though now in America, she
suffers discrimination and gets
accursed due to the colour of
her skin. However, the
difference is that such
attitudes aren't hurtful much.
But she continues to
remember the Dalit caste
injustices and sex differences
that were hurled upon her, and
her siblings when they were
growing up in India.
This book is her memoircum-
autobiography. Gidla
casually hints at the sad and
hurtful plight of the Black in
the US over the years… that's
still rampant till today. She
doesn't discuss the Blacks'
horrendous predicament
today, even in the 21st century
US-- segregation in schools,
society, jobs, education and
above all of being shunned in
political, social even religious
circles.
Gidla Sujatha
Even in the eyes of local
laws, they're treated
prejudicially and differently compared to the Whites in
police stations, jails, Blacks
have their separate cultures,
churches, media outlets, partly
even in universities, colleges
and schools. Though numerous
American laws apparently
forbid such attitudes and even
the atmosphere, things are no
so rosy as Gidla had thought,
and now she experiences day
in and day out in new home in
new country. But she is not so
vocal in details these.
Obviously !
The book's first 31-paged
extended Introduction and
Prelude, the author sums up
the events and circumstances
that impelled her family and
many others like her, to
consent conversion. While she
repeats umpteen times, with
profuse pain and immense
resentmentthe Dalits'
'untouchable' status in the
Hindu society: 'The caste you're
born in determines the kind of
(lowly) work you do.' The last
chapter, titled "Afterword",
makes hair-raising on-the-spot
narration of the state of
grinding poverty would be hard
to envisionin today's India.
She vividly recollects
innumerable humiliations that
Dalits were made to undergo
to earn their meagre wages
after prolonged hard work in
fields as landless labourers,
underfed domestic helps, and
were made to live only in areas
segregated from locations
where caste Hindus inhabited.
They were allowed to eat using
only different utensils, and not
come close to the so-called
upper caste men and women.
Gidla describes at length her
mother Manjula's 'battles with caste and women's oppression'
and, … page after page, she
takes the reader into her
family's early days fight with
social ill-treatment they were
meted with. Gidla's uncle K.
Satyamurty, a brilliant
propagandist for Communists,
was a committed follower of
Chinese leader Mao, and was a
radical revolutionary and was a
most wanted man by the
police. Being an extreme
hardliner, he was expelled
from his subversive and
resurgent outfit, People's War
Group. Gidla who initially
followed his ideology, but
when she was jailed for three
months, she quit.
Gidla's account of
Satyamurthy's seditious
activities runs though the
book. To the reader's disliking
though.
Moreover, the complicated
details of the story of the Gidla
family's rescue-process won't
interest a perceptive reader.
But the passion and
singlemindedness she
researched these from piles of
records and personal
interviews spread over two
visits, accompanied by her
assistant, would have cost a
tidy amount provided by
Christian sponsors keen to
reflect that savage,
brutalendless torture the
'converts' were said to have
been saved from.
For example, hardly anyone
will be interested to know how
and whyGidla's mother,
Manjula, 'sent word to Paulus
asking to see him and waited
on a bench outside his office.
Her family's financial situation
was quite bad. Her brother had three small children. Without
her salary, they could not eat.
She desperately needed the
job.' Trivial details of Gidla's
distantrelations' problems fill
the pages that have little, if
any, relevance with the book's
theme.
Moreover, there are
numerous factual
m i s r e p r e s e n t a t i o n s ,
grammatical-editorial errors
and unexplained details.
Perhaps since the editors were
unfamiliar with background,
such discrepancies were bound
to occur. The chapters have no
headings, there's no index;
poor translations of Telugu
language words.
Finally, listless details
spanning over some 150 pages
may not have even been
intelligible to the book critics
who debated at length in
reviews in print and electronic
media -- BBC, NBC, London
Economist , The Guardian,
London Times, The New York
Times, and numerous other
media outlets in the West, but
all have welcomed the book in
roaring words and reeling out
statistics on Dalits' place in
Indian scoeity.
Prompted to publicize
Gilda's critical conditions to
escape from which poverty,
and of many other poor people
who were 'voluntarily'
resorting to 'conversion'
actuated by better future
prospects after embracing
Christianity.
However, scholars of
sociology, anthropology and
political science could find the
book of limited interest. The
book's title cover and blurb
leave much to be desired.